Eating Disorders and Addiction:
Finding Treatment for Both
By Peter Hayton
Clinically reviewed by Dr. Terry Spokes, Clinical Director. Last reviewed November 2026.
Peter Hayton
Peter Hayton is an Australian psychologist with more than 25 years’ experience in psychotherapy and design of addiction treatment programmes. For eight years, he was founding Clinical Director of The Banyans, a private residential addiction treatment centre in south-east Queensland. At The Winslow, Peter helps clients build resilience and rediscover great health during their residential stay.
Much has been written about co-occurring mental health and addiction or dependency concerns. Less attention has been given to an eating disorder or eating issue that occurs alongside alcohol, drug or behavioural dependency.
This article sets out considerations for loved ones and professionals looking for appropriate treatment options, and for those of us who are living with both.
In this article
1. Two conditions, two treatment traditions2. Isolation and the need for connection3. Motivation and readiness for change4. Physical health and medical support5. Knowing the harm and continuing anyway6. Neurodivergence, trauma and individual needs7. Shame, self-regard and the setting8. What to look for in a residential programme
Two conditions, two treatment traditions
The pathway to working on addiction and dependency concerns is well worn. Treatment programmes draw on decades of treatment modalities that sit outside the hospital setting. The Minnesota model, practised for almost 90 years, provides non-hospital approaches to addiction and dependency treatment.
The same cannot be said for those of us struggling with eating concerns or an associated disorder. The hospital is so often where an eating disorder is seen to be appropriately treated and, for more chronic presentations, rightly so. But for many people with mild to moderate eating issues, the choice of treatment needs careful consideration when there are also substance, alcohol or behavioural dependency and addiction presentations.
Clinicians focused on the modern treatment of eating disorders are unlikely to make the mistake of seeing the condition as a passing phase that can easily be fixed. Careful consideration of the appropriateness of treatment options is therefore important when seeking to address co-occurring dependency and addiction concerns. Residential programmes that focus specifically on eating issues often list no active substance dependence among their admission criteria, as two recent studies of residential eating disorder treatment describe.
So too, treatment professionals working regularly in addiction and dependency understand how prevalent these conditions are, and how difficult they are to shift. These are difficult and often lifelong conditions to treat. Periods of abstinence or remission are often accompanied by episodes of relapse or re-presentation.
For both conditions, time out for sustained and more focused treatment is commonplace. For addiction, that has meant the rehab or residential programme. For an eating disorder and associated concerns, it has in the past meant the hospital.
The question remains how we can offer the most effective step forward in life when these concerns co-occur. How can we provide environments that support, and offer hope to, those living with both eating issues and addiction or dependency concerns?
Addiction or dependency and eating issues or disorders share a number of common considerations. Six of them follow.
Isolation and the need for connection
Conditions that lead people into isolation, or to a loss of positive interpersonal contact, are quite damaging. Humans are, by nature, animals that do far better when they have positive and safe connections with other humans.
Some addiction and dependency presentations might originate in a social or party atmosphere, but most of us find ourselves left in isolation. We hurt others and damage our interpersonal relationships, leaving us alone. Addiction or dependency results in the breakdown of the social fabric. Feelings of rejection and isolation are powerful parts of the concern.
Eating disorders and associated concerns most often result in a dual experience of alienation. There is alienation from social networks, due to symptom concealment, and alienation from interpersonal and associated psychological connections. For both presentations, loneliness acts as both an aetiological driver and a maintaining factor. A 2012 review of the research describes this link in eating disorders.
When considering treatment options, a focus on opportunities to overcome isolation is important. The value of residential treatment, for both eating disorders and dependency, is that its community aspects assist with the socialisation needed to start the move back into the world outside the eating concerns and addiction matters. When we look for treatment options that leave us further isolated, we prolong the recovery process.
Motivation and readiness for change
Finding the resources needed to step into recovery is a concern for any condition. Medical teams regularly train in modalities such as motivational interviewing (MI) to better equip themselves to ‘move’ clients into treatment.
A 2012 systematic review by Macdonald and colleagues indicates that motivational interviewing is a common therapeutic approach with eating disorder clients. The studies in that review indicate the potential for using MI in the field of eating disorders, particularly with respect to ‘readiness for change’. It may be that MI is a behaviour change process designed to be helpful when an individual is not ready to instigate change.
We see the same dynamic in working with people struggling with addiction and dependency concerns, where motivational interviewing is an important part of the treatment protocols. The stages of change model, used regularly in work with addiction and dependency clients, highlights and makes room for a progression towards longer-lasting changes that lead to positive health and lifestyle.
Addiction and dependency have a greater body of research than eating issues, including strong longer-term studies. That research mostly indicates that they respond well to motivational interviewing approaches. A 2010 meta-analysis of 119 studies by Lundahl and colleagues suggests that overly rigid, manualised protocols can reduce effectiveness. Outcomes are enhanced when programmes invoke the ‘MI spirit’, which matters more than rigid procedural compliance.
Treatment for both addiction or dependency and eating issues benefits from strong alignment between the client and the treatment programme and its professionals. In both conditions, the ‘in control’ and ‘out of control’ parts of the client’s life are something of a focus, along with the isolation. Clients therefore benefit from a stronger alignment with, and understanding of, the approaches being used.
When selecting a treatment programme for co-occurring issues, it is important to move away from single-stream or overly controlling and rigid treatment options.
Physical health and medical support
If you have journeyed with an eating disorder client, or suffered some eating issues yourself, you will appreciate the strong fixation on a set of behaviours that become entrenched, despite the knowledge that they can lead to the most serious health issues. So it is when working with, or moving away from, addiction and dependency concerns. The fixation seems irrational and certainly leads to significant health concerns, along with the isolation mentioned above.
Treatment programmes with a strong focus on physical health become paramount when providing appropriate support for co-occurring eating disorder and addiction or dependency presentations. Availability of nursing and medical support, along with appropriate protocols for health checks and access to a variety of specialised health practitioners, is most valuable.
In our modern world of international travel, it is not unusual for clients, families and their home-based treating professionals to recommend residential settings overseas and away from home. Appropriate specialised treatment is difficult to find in many locations. It is therefore important to choose a residential treatment provider in a country that provides premium options for complex care.
Countries that dominate volume-driven medical tourism and routine care are much less suitable for residential treatment of eating issues alongside dependency or addiction concerns. Regulatory rigour and safety standards are important factors in managing the health of people presenting with both eating issues and addiction or dependency.
Knowing the harm and continuing anyway
One important commonality between eating disorders and addiction or dependency concerns is the tension between recognising that a behaviour is harmful and feeling compelled to continue it. Understanding this tension means looking beyond the behaviour itself to the beliefs and social expectations that give it meaning.
In the context of eating disorders, the pursuit of an ‘ideal’ weight or body size may reflect internalised messages about what a person should look like and how closely they should conform to that ideal. The issue is therefore not simply a particular weight or size, but the significance attached to achieving it.
A comparable pattern can be seen when an ‘ideal’ night out is understood to involve alcohol, drugs or other potentially harmful behaviours. A similar pattern of thought treats them as the ‘best’ or ‘only’ way to relieve stress. If consumption is treated as an expected part of the experience, questioning it may also mean challenging an accepted idea of what enjoyment or social participation should involve. Likewise, where drinking or substance use is linked to stress relief, the question then becomes ‘do I not deserve to release the stress?’
These examples do not make eating disorders and addiction interchangeable. Rather, they illustrate how beliefs absorbed from the wider social world can become personal rules that are difficult to challenge, even when their consequences are damaging. The thought, ‘This behaviour is causing me harm; I should change’, can exist alongside a powerful attachment to the very pattern the person wants to leave behind. Awareness of harm, including the impact on loved ones, does not necessarily resolve that conflict.
When considering treatment, it is therefore valuable to look for an approach that explores the person’s understanding of their behaviour, rather than assuming that recognition of its consequences will be enough to change it. Attending to these shared tensions allows the similarities between the two presentations to inform care while keeping the individual’s particular experiences and needs in view.
Neurodivergence, trauma and individual needs
When eating disorders and addiction or dependency concerns occur alongside neurodivergence, a history of trauma, or differing attachment experiences, treatment planning needs to consider the person rather than the presenting behaviours alone. A useful question for clients, families and referring professionals is whether a programme has a multifaceted approach to presenting needs while maintaining appropriate clinical and medical safeguards.
Highly rigid or confrontational programmes may leave little room for these differences. However, structure itself need not be the problem. The distinction is between a predictable, supportive framework and an inflexible expectation that every person should engage with treatment in the same way.
Research on adapted eating disorder care for autistic people offers a relevant example. In a 2024 qualitative evaluation of the Pathway for Eating disorders and Autism developed from Clinical Experience (PEACE), Li and colleagues interviewed clinicians about adaptations to treatment. Clinicians described greater flexibility and individualisation, improved understanding of the perspectives of the people in their care, and increased engagement. Adaptations included attention to sensory needs and communication support.
This supports the case for bespoke care: retaining evidence-based treatment within a personalised framework that recognises individual needs and supports participation. The study concerned autism and eating disorders, rather than all forms of neurodivergence or co-occurring addiction. Its findings reflect clinicians’ experiences rather than proof of superior recovery outcomes. Nevertheless, it provides a useful starting point when considering residential treatment options.
Families, referring professionals and clients might ask how a service identifies individual communication and sensory needs, agrees adjustments collaboratively, and reviews whether those adjustments are helping. Where trauma is also part of the person’s history, they can ask how this will inform the treatment plan. The emphasis should be on a coherent approach that offers various therapies, rather than on the assumption that one approach will suit everyone.
Shame, self-regard and the setting
One of the curious aspects of addiction or dependency presentations, and one quite similar to what we notice with eating issues, is a denouncing of primary needs and a focus on other ‘powerful’ feelings, the somatic components related to harm. Consider the intense physiological sensations of hunger or, for some, of feeling over-full. Consider how alike these are to the feelings of being unwell or coming down for the substance user. Sensations of failure, regret and shame are common to both presentations.
Treatment programmes built on a strong sense of positive self-regard, which rebuild the sense of self and related compassion, are paramount in moving these clients towards health and healing. Let’s face it, the physical environment of a hospital is designed primarily to promote biological and physical health. To create a sense of positive self-regard, a setting that is more holistic and homely is helpful.
The residential setting of many addiction or dependency programmes is often just this: a more homely, residentially oriented setting, better suited to working on notions of self-care and respect. It is in the context of building a stronger focus on wellness that the journey of letting go of the powerful harm-related aspects of their lives can begin.
Recent authors such as Dr. Anna Lembke, in her 2021 book Dopamine Nation, have popularised the research behind the balance of pain and pleasure. Lembke indicates that, as the body and human system seek balance and homeostasis, pain is activated more often in situations where we have been activating the pleasure side through substance use. That pain, often emotional, easily leads to self-deprecating thoughts.
The powerful feelings of harm so enmeshed in both eating issues and addiction or dependency presentations require caring and nurturing environments, in which people can rediscover what feeling well looks like.
What to look for in a residential programme
Finding residential treatment programmes suited to supporting the co-presentation of eating issues and addiction or dependency is a challenge. A residential setting that maintains an attitude of unconditional positive regard, alongside structure and the associated medical support, is important in any treatment programme. It is more so for these co-presenting conditions.
Teams of experienced and licensed doctors, therapists and nurses are better positioned to treat eating disorder and addiction or dependency presentations. Associated care staff are also an essential factor, but doctors and nurses are essential in providing the kind of support that eating disorder presentations require. Ideally, nurses are available for oversight and treatment 24 hours a day, seven days a week. This is most helpful not just for stabilisation in the early stages of addiction or dependency treatment, but through the whole programme for eating disorder presentations.
The goal of rehabilitation in addiction or dependency is the same as for eating issues: to promote independence and a self-directed focus on a healthier life. That goal is best supported when therapists are experienced across a range of presenting issues. This is not a one-size-fits-all client population. Non-punitive approaches work best alongside both addiction or dependency and eating issues presentations. Understanding the connections between the two, and the requirements for specialised treatment, supports better outcomes for clients.
Finally, residential treatment centres provide an appropriate setting in which to bring these supports together. They do so only when embedded in a local and wider community health care system that is extensive enough to provide real safety and effective medical treatment beyond the residential environment.
Talking to us
If you are exploring treatment for yourself or someone you care about, you can read more about our programme or speak confidentially with our clinical team. We are happy to talk through whether The Winslow is the right fit and, if it isn’t, to help you find the level of care that is.
Sources: Clague CA, Conti J, Ramjan L, et al. “Find a life worth living”: An analysis of experiences of residential treatment for eating disorders. Eating Behaviors. 2025;57:101950; Day S, Houlihan C, Mitchison D, et al. Pilot Study Outcomes and Recommendations from Developing an Australian Residential Treatment for Eating Disorders. Adolescents. 2024;4(3):324–334; Lembke A. Dopamine Nation: Finding Balance in the Age of Indulgence. Headline, 2021; Levine MP. Loneliness and Eating Disorders. The Journal of Psychology. 2012;146(1–2):243–257; Li Z, Hutchings-Hay C, Byford S, Tchanturia K. A qualitative evaluation of the pathway for eating disorders and autism developed from clinical experience (PEACE): clinicians’ perspective. Frontiers in Psychiatry. 2024;15:1332441; Lundahl BW, Kunz C, Brownell C, et al. A Meta-Analysis of Motivational Interviewing: Twenty-Five Years of Empirical Studies. Research on Social Work Practice. 2010;20(2):137–160; Macdonald P, Hibbs R, Corfield F, Treasure J. The use of motivational interviewing in eating disorders: A systematic review. Psychiatry Research. 2012;200(1):1–11.
Speak with a clinician
If you’re considering treatment for yourself or someone you care about, a confidential conversation can help clarify whether The Winslow is the right fit.
Our team is available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.
